European Art

Hans von Aachen: Allegory of Peace, Art and Abundance

Hans von Aachen, Allegory of Peace, Art and Abundance: a reclining nude extends a branch between a companion holding an armillary sphere and a woman seen from behind offering a gilded cup, above discarded weapons.
Hans von Aachen, Allegory of Peace, Art and Abundance, 1602. Oil on canvas, 197 × 142 cm. Hermitage, St Petersburg.

Light falls almost wholly on one body in Hans von Aachen's Allegory of Peace, Art and Abundance: a pale, fair-haired nude who reclines across the middle of a tall canvas, one arm extended with a leafy branch, while two companions press towards her out of the shadow. The picture was painted in 1602 by the German artist born in Cologne in 1552, who worked for Emperor Rudolf II in Prague and died there in 1615. It is executed in oil on canvas, measures 197 × 142 cm, and belongs today to the Hermitage in St Petersburg. A title that also circulates in the form Allegory of Peace, Abundance and the Arts names three abstractions without saying which figure embodies which, and the painting gives no inscription to settle the matter.

That silence is part of what has kept the work in discussion. Its attributes can be read with some confidence; its occasion, on the other hand, has divided the specialists in Rudolfine art, who have tied it to two quite different arenas of imperial policy at the opening of the seventeenth century.

Composition and Light in the Hermitage Canvas

Heavy curtains of a deep, shot red hang from the upper edge and are gathered back to either side, opening a view of pale sky crossed by dark, lobed foliage. The device turns the whole picture into something close to a stage. Within that opening the three figures are packed tightly together, their limbs overlapping so that it is not always immediately clear where one body ends and the next begins. The interlocking poses recall those of his Venus and Adonis.

The nude dominates by light as much as by size. Her body runs on a long diagonal from the upper right, where her head tilts towards the beholder and her gaze is turned outwards, down to the lower left, where a single sandalled foot rests among discarded arms. Her right arm, outstretched, carries the branch into the upper left corner, against the red of the curtain. The pose twists through the torso and hips, with the shoulders turned one way and the legs another; it is a figure built for display, and the flesh is modelled in cool, polished half-tones that set it apart from everything around it. A transparent white veil lies across her lap without concealing anything. A narrow gilded chain crosses her chest, a red ribbon flutters at her left shoulder, and a thin fillet with a small ornament sits in her hair.

Behind her, half in shadow, a second figure with dark hair and a darker complexion leans in, wrapped in a red mantle over a blue-green garment. An arm passes behind the nude's neck, and a hand, which seems to belong to this companion, rests on her left shoulder. The face is turned in three-quarter view, the eyes directed sideways and upwards, away from the beholder.

The third figure is seen almost entirely from behind. Her back and shoulders are bare, a white chemise slipping from them; a mantle of golden ochre falls around her lower body, and her hair is braided and coiled at the back of the head, pinned with a small jewelled ornament set with red stones. She raises a gilded footed cup filled with something red towards the reclining woman. Placed at the lower edge and cut by the frame, she works as a repoussoir, pushing the luminous nude back into the picture space while drawing the viewer's eye along her own line of sight.

Branch, Sphere and Cup: Reading the Personifications

The three figures

Each figure is given at least one object, and these objects carry most of the allegory. The branch held aloft by the central nude, with its narrow leaves, is the attribute that most readily answers to Peace in the title, and her placement at the centre of the light suits the principal theme. Against the curtain on the left, a gilt armillary sphere, its rings mounted on a staff, is held in a darker hand that rises from the red drapery; it appears to be held by the second figure. A model of the heavens points towards learning and the liberal disciplines, so the half-shadowed companion is the likeliest candidate for Art. The cup offered from the foreground, together with the fruit heaped at the right edge, where the nude's left hand rests on apples and a pomegranate spilling from a horn-shaped container, gathers the signs of plenty around the figure of Abundance.

This distribution is an inference from the attributes, and it should be held as such. The objects overlap in a manner that is typical of the painting as a whole: the sphere belongs to one figure but is set beside the branch of another, and the fruit of Abundance lies under the hand of Peace. Von Aachen seems to have wanted the three abstractions to read as a single, entwined condition, and the tight grouping of the bodies makes the same point visually.

The still life of arms

The lower part of the canvas is occupied by the instruments of war, laid aside. A steel helmet lies at the far left; nearby is a curved scabbard with gilded mounts, and a long weapon crosses the foreground diagonally, its shaft ending in a tuft of red, close to the hand of the woman who holds the cup. Blades and dark shafts cross the bottom edge, and a large sphere drawn with meridian lines, apparently a globe, rests beneath them. The sandalled foot of the nude touches this pile. Whatever the precise political reference, the arrangement states plainly enough that peace and its benefits rest on weapons that are no longer in use, and that this peace extends, in the logic of the picture, over a world represented by the globe.

Hans von Aachen's Allegory of Peace, Art and Abundance and the Politics of 1602

The painting had a reputation from the start. As Larry Silver's review of the conference volume Hans von Aachen in Context (Prague, Institute of Art History, 2012) notes, the work was cited by the painter-biographer Van Mander, and modern scholarship has approached it with the benefit of Joachim Jacoby's catalogue raisonné of 2003 and the exhibition Hans von Aachen (1552–1615): Court Artist in Europe, shown at Aachen, Prague and Vienna in 2010–11.

Two readings stand out. Thomas DaCosta Kaufmann had suggested that the canvas celebrated a “victory” in the continuing war against the Ottoman Turks. In his essay for the 2012 volume, Thomas Fusenig argued instead that it arose as imperial propaganda from Rudolf II's efforts at pacification in the Netherlands, and he advanced the hypothesis that the work was closely connected, in the Netherlands, with Johan van Oldenbarnevelt through the imperial legate Count Simon VI. The two proposals need not exclude every element of the other, but they point to different audiences and different political horizons, and neither has displaced the other as an agreed interpretation.

The Ottoman hypothesis has a clear context in the painter's own work. A University of Texas thesis on the subject situates von Aachen as court artist to Rudolf II in Prague and dates the Long War against the Ottoman Empire to 1593–1606; it also records that between 1604 and 1606 he produced a series of small Allegories on the Long Turkish War, which the emperor kept bound in a red book in his Kunstkammer. The theme occupied him earlier as well, as the National Gallery of Art's pen and watercolour drawing Allegory on the Turkish Wars, dated around 1600, shows. The Hermitage painting stands apart from these works in scale and in its avoidance of identifiable battles or rulers. Neither rulers nor captives are identified, and no named place appears in it, and that very generality is what allows it to be attached to more than one political situation.

Sculptural Models and the Prague Court Style

The long, slender proportions of the nude have been connected with sculpture. In the same Prague volume, Edgar Lein linked the painting with the slender female figures around Bartolomeo Ammannati's Neptune Fountain in Florence, as part of a broader argument about von Aachen's debt to Italian Mannerist sculpture; he also related other figures by the painter to Giambologna, among them the Saint Sebastian of 1594 in St Michael's, Munich, which he compared with the Flying Mercury of 1588. In the Hermitage canvas the sculptural sense is evident in the clear contour of the reclining body and in the way its surface is finished like polished stone, while the colour of the drapery and the warm darkness around the figures remain resolutely painterly.

The presence of Art among the personifications fits the ambitions of the Prague court, whose political use of allegory also informs his Triumph of Truth. According to Silver's account of Lars Olof Larsson's contribution, Rudolf II sought in 1595 to raise court painting to the standing of a liberal art, and von Aachen's design Minerva Leads Painting to the Liberal Arts, engraved by Sadeler, has come to stand for that programme. Dorothy Limouze, writing on the same print, drew attention to the prominence of Astronomy among the liberal arts in Rudolfine Prague, where Kepler carried out his research. The armillary sphere in the Hermitage allegory belongs to the same intellectual world, although the shared attribute alone does not establish a direct connection between that print and the painting.

Related allegorical imagery also travelled beyond the court in reproductive form. The Los Angeles County Museum of Art holds an engraving by Johan Barra after Hans von Aachen, published by Anthonie de Later and dated to about 1600–1634, under the title Allegory of Peace with the Arts and Ceres. The museum record describes two intertwined female figures, one holding a laurel branch and the other reclining with flowers, together with an armillary sphere and Latin text below. With two figures instead of three, the print cannot be a simple copy of the Hermitage composition, and the catalogue entry does not state its relationship to the canvas; it shows, however, that the pairing of the branch and the celestial sphere in a single image of peace and the arts circulated under von Aachen's name in the Netherlands.