Byzantine Art

Saints Cosmas and Damian: Wall Painting at Gregoriou Monastery

Wall painting of Saints Cosmas and Damian at Gregoriou Monastery: two young bearded saints in blue, red and floral robes, each holding a medicine casket
Saint Damian (left) and Saint Cosmas (right), north wall of the naos, katholikon of Gregoriou Monastery, Mount Athos, painted in 1779 by the Kastorian painters Gabriel and Gregorios.

On the north wall of the katholikon at Gregoriou Monastery on Mount Athos, Saints Cosmas and Damian stand side by side at full length, each holding a gold-coloured medicine casket out from his body. The wall painting belongs to the decoration of 1779. That year the renovated church of the monastery (the name is also transliterated Grigoriou) was painted by two artists from Kastoria, the hieromonk Gabriel and Gregorios, who described themselves as “most humble painters”.

White majuscule inscriptions on the dark ground name the two physicians. Read in full, they give Ὁ ἅγιος Δαμιανός above the figure on the left and Ὁ ἅγιος Κοσμᾶς above the figure on the right. In both, the adjective is contracted and the final sigma of each word is reduced to a curling stroke that drops below the line. Within Kosmas, the sigma takes the lunate form. Damian’s place on the left deserves notice. A Cretan icon in the British Museum, which its curators connect with Emmanuel Tzanes or his workshop, has the opposite arrangement: Kosmas stands on the left and Damian on the right, the order in which the two names are usually given. At Gregoriou the positions are exchanged.

Saints Cosmas and Damian in the Naos Programme

The walls of the naos at Gregoriou are given to martyrs, military saints and the great figures of monasticism. Read clockwise from the south wall, the series opens with Panteleimon, another healing saint, who holds his medical instruments in his left hand and the martyr’s cross in his right. Demetrios, Nestor and Merkourios follow in the south choir. The desert fathers fill the west wall, and on its northern half the monastic figures continue as far as Simon, founder of neighbouring Simonopetra. Then come the physicians, on the north wall, and after them, in the north choir, the military saints Niketas, James the Persian and Menas.

The two physicians therefore stand between the founders of monastic life and a company of armed martyrs, with Panteleimon on the opposite wall. According to the British Museum’s notes on the Tzanes panel, some images insert Panteleimon between Cosmas and Damian. Here the three healers are spread across two walls, and the pair keeps a field of its own.

Soldiers carry much of the weight of this programme. Military saints are unusually numerous and prominent in the naos for an Athonite katholikon, and in the lowest zone they stand almost at life size, forming something like a painted base for the decoration above. The apse Platytera belongs to the same campaign of 1779. In the main spaces of the church, the many cycles and themes of that campaign are arranged without losing their monumental scale or their proper relationship to the architecture.

Medicine Caskets and the Instruments of the Anargyroi

The caskets are the most carefully worked objects in the composition. Damian holds his on the flat of his left hand, a fold of his bluish mantle hanging beneath it. It stands open, the lid raised upright, showing a grid of compartments filled with red, white and greyish-blue matter, with a narrow drawer on the front and a small central fitting. Cosmas holds his casket slightly tilted, so that its compartments are seen from above, and a small painted ornament marks the front panel. Both boxes are ochre-gold and decorated with tiny motifs that imitate inlay or painted wood.

Cosmas holds a long, slender white spoon diagonally between the fingers of his right hand, much as one holds a pen; a small cross marks one end, and a curved bowl the other. Damian raises his right hand before his chest with thumb and forefinger touching. No instrument can be made out there, and the paint of the mantle around the hand is abraded.

These are the attributes of the Anargyroi, the healers “without silver”, so called because they treated the sick without payment. The Menil Collection describes a sixteenth-century icon, probably Serbian, in which Damian holds a spatula for applying ointment. The British Museum’s commentary speaks of cross-tipped spoons used to dispense medicine. The cross-tipped spoon at Gregoriou belongs to this familiar repertoire. Because the image was tied so closely to pharmacy and medical practice, it lasted across many media. A doctoral thesis on the cult of the saints on Chios follows it through icons, engravings, medals and the seals of medical guilds, and medical and pharmaceutical equipment stays the constant element throughout.

No additional figure is painted above the two saints. The British Museum notes trace the frontal format with Christ above to twelfth-century wall paintings at Kastoria, the city the Gregoriou painters came from. The same notes say the standard image often left Christ out, even after 1453. At Gregoriou the dark field holds only the inscriptions.

Floral Costume and an Exchange of Colours

Beneath the mantles, the dress keeps the scheme that museum catalogues record for the pair: a long tunic, a shorter dalmatic over it and a himation, all garments of Byzantine secular dress. The surfaces of those layers belong to the eighteenth century. Damian’s knee-length overgarment is white, scattered with carnation-like blossoms on leafy stems and small rosettes in red, green and brown, and finished with a broad gold hem set with painted stones. Under it, a salmon-pink tunic streaked with white highlights falls to a second gold border just above the ankles. Both saints wear wide jewelled collars edged with pearl dots and set with red, green and dark lozenges and small cross-shaped flowers. Gold cuffs close their sleeves.

Across the whole Gregoriou decoration, from the Samaritan woman’s dress to the robes of the Ten Virgins, costume and its ornament come from the folk art and taste of the period, and large plant motifs and strong colours are among its marks. Colour is the strongest element of the ensemble. The range is narrow and saturated: pure red, light blue, gold and white, with green used sparingly. At times the colours are set deliberately against one another, as in the military saints of the choirs, whose uniforms alternate between red and pale blue.

The two physicians are built on just such a counterpoint. Damian’s mantle is a cool bluish grey; Cosmas’ is a deep crimson. The red of Cosmas’ mantle returns in Damian’s long tunic, softened to pink, while the white of Damian’s floral overgarment becomes Cosmas’ long tunic, shaded with ochre in broad vertical folds. The colours of the sleeves follow the same pattern: pink at Damian’s wrist, white at Cosmas’. Cosmas’ overgarment, a pale sea-green with a gold hem of red and dark green lozenges, is the largest cool passage in either figure. The ground behind them is nearly black and turns bluish in places. Both stand on a strip of green, and a red band frames the field.

Faces, Bodies and Two Kastorian Painters

The heads share a type and differ in small details. Both men are young, with short brown beards, drooping moustaches and hair cut close around the brow. Each has large dark eyes under heavy lids, arched brows, a long straight nose and a small mouth with thin lips: the fine, carefully drawn features found throughout this decoration. Damian’s face is the warmer of the two, its ochre flesh tending towards orange and its contours firmer. Cosmas’ face is paler, with more olive in the shadows.

In both faces the cool greenish and umber underpainting shows at the edges, and thin light strokes run across the forehead and along the bridge of the nose. This cool proplasmos faintly recalls the method associated with Panselinos and the painters around him. In the eighteenth century Kosmas of Lemnos used it with particular success and consistency in the chapel of St Demetrios at Vatopedi.

The bodies are slender and carry little weight. The garments almost merge with the figures inside them, and the legs below the hems are thin. The feet turn outward and sit rather flatly on the green strip, which makes them the least assured drawing in the composition. Weaknesses of this kind, especially in the feet, recur among the standing saints of the church. The drapery, by contrast, keeps a fairly organic quality: the folds of Damian’s pink tunic are laid down in long white strokes, without the hardened schematism of later post-Byzantine painting.

It cannot be said whether Gabriel or Gregorios painted either figure. Across the katholikon, the visible differences between the two hands are limited, among them a broader greenish proplasmos, and they are too slight to separate the painters’ work. The likeliest explanation is that the two men worked together on almost every composition and saint, with nearly identical handling. The difference in flesh tone between Damian and Cosmas is real, but on its own it points to no particular painter.

Athonite Painting in 1779: The Hermeneia and Popular Taste

The Gregoriou paintings were made about half a century after Dionysios of Fourna wrote his Hermeneia of the Art of Painting, around 1729 to 1733. The manual codified the techniques and iconography of its time and gathered older experience from Athonite works and earlier manuscript guides. The iconographic formulations at Gregoriou come very close to its descriptions. It is hard to prove whether the Kastorian painters worked directly from the text or simply shared the climate that shaped Athonite decoration in the second half of the eighteenth century, and the second explanation seems the more likely. Those decades saw intense painting activity in many Athonite monasteries, alongside the philokalic revival whose leading theological voice was St Nikodemos the Hagiorite.

Orthodox church painting of that century followed two broad tendencies, and both were present on Athos. One sought a return to the models of Panselinos, with Dionysios as its theorist. The other leaned towards popular taste and is represented by Panagiotis of Ioannina and the Epirote painters of Chionades and Kapesovo. Painters from Kastoria, like their Epirote neighbours, worked across almost the whole of mainland Greece, and Gabriel and Gregorios must have earned some reputation before they were called to the Holy Mountain. In this pair of physicians both tendencies can be traced on a single wall. The cool modelling of the faces looks back to the older Athonite models, while the flowered dress and strong colour of the garments come from the popular art of the day. The drawing, generally precise and sure, still follows the Cretan painting that had survived on Athos, changed by the three centuries since.