Prophet Elijah Mosaic, Holy Apostles, Thessaloniki
Locks of hair in slate blue, white and pale buff tesserae sweep back from the brow of the Prophet Elijah in this mosaic detail from the Church of the Holy Apostles in Thessaloniki. Beneath them the face turns in three-quarter view towards the right of the composition, and the one fully visible eye, dark and heavy-lidded, looks sideways past the edge of the field. The head belongs to the mosaic decoration that Patriarch Niphon I commissioned for the church he founded in 1310–1314, a programme that, together with the mosaics of the Chora and Pammakaristos monasteries in Constantinople, is counted among the last examples of such decoration in Byzantium and among the finest achievements of Palaiologan art.
What the photograph shows is a detail: the head, much of the beard and a little of the ground around it. That is enough for close study of how a fourteenth-century mosaicist built a face from coloured tesserae. It also brings forward a question that the detail cannot fully settle by itself, namely where in the church's decorative scheme this Elijah stood.
Face, Gaze and the Modelling of Flesh
Turned towards his own left, the prophet shows the viewer most of the right side of his face. His right eye sits near the centre of the field, large, almond-shaped, ringed by a dark contour, and the pupil lies towards its inner corner so that the glance travels towards the viewer's right. Of the left eye only a small dark area is visible at the far contour of the face, where the foreshortened cheek meets the background. The effect is one of attention directed elsewhere: the figure responds to something, or someone, beyond the edge of the detail.
Small tesserae, set in curving rows that follow the forms, make up the flesh. Salmon pinks, warm orange-browns and creams carry the planes of the cheek and nose, and a few nearly white cubes pick out the bridge of the nose and the cheekbone as highlights. Under the eye runs a crescent of yellow and olive-green tesserae, the cool shadow that Byzantine flesh modelling habitually sets against warm light. A dark reddish line traces the long nose down to the moustache, and at the mouth a cluster of deep red cubes marks the lips. Above the eye a dark arched line, doubled by lighter tesserae, gives the brow its weight.
The handling is broad and lively for so small a surface. Rows of tesserae change direction abruptly at the cheekbone, the eye socket and the nostril, and the modelling relies on these changes of direction as much as on colour.
Hair, Beard and the Colour of the Tesserae
Hair and beard occupy more of the detail than the face, and here the mosaicist worked with a freer hand and, by all appearances, with larger cubes. The hair is laid in long S-shaped bands, each bounded by a dark line and filled with alternating rows of grey-blue, white, buff and light brown. These bands curl away from the forehead towards the left of the image and fall in loose loops beside the cheek, so that the head seems set within a moving mass of locks.
Two strips of bright blue tesserae run down beside the face, one along the hair at the cheek nearer the viewer and another through the beard below the mouth. At this saturation, blue gives the hair a pronounced chromatic accent, separating it from the flesh and sharpening the contour where tonal contrast alone would have been weak.
The beard is darker and warmer. Olive, ochre and gold-yellow tesserae alternate with black lines and thin streaks of white, and beneath the lower lip, on the right of the image, a tuft of the beard coils into a near-spiral of white and pale yellow cubes. Such a rendering of unkempt, vigorous hair and beard suits the ascetic prophet of the Old Testament, whose untamed appearance distinguished him in Byzantine imagery from the more ordered heads of apostles and hierarchs.
The Prophet Elijah Mosaic and the Programme of the Naos
The decoration of the naos of the Holy Apostles follows the standard Middle and Late Byzantine arrangement. The dome shows the Pantokrator with prophets, the pendentives the four Evangelists, and the vaults scenes from the Dodekaorton, the cycle of the Great Feasts. The University of Sussex mosaic database specifies ten prophets in the dome, together with Christ, the Evangelists and the Mandylion, while the vaults of the cross arms, the arches and the west wall carry the Feast scenes. Among the Feasts are the Nativity, Transfiguration, Entry into Jerusalem, Resurrection, Crucifixion and Dormition.
Elijah could therefore appear in two places within this scheme, and the detail on its own does not identify which. In the Gospel accounts Moses and Elijah appear beside Christ on the mountain (Matthew 17:3), and the Transfiguration mosaic of the Holy Apostles accordingly includes both prophets. The head's turn and its sideways gaze would be consistent with a figure directed towards the central Christ of that scene. A prophet in the drum of the dome, however, may also be turned and animated. Without a view of the figure's body, scroll or setting, the attribution of this head to one or the other ensemble remains a matter for the full documentation of the church rather than for the crop.
Patriarch Niphon and the Dating of the Mosaics
The date of the decoration is tied to its patron. According to Marina Toumpouri's entry on the church, the katholikon was built between 1310 and 1314 by Patriarch Niphon I, as the inscription on the marble lintel above the main entrance attests, together with monograms on the west façade capitals and on bricks. The inscriptions record Niphon's foundation, while the mosaic decoration is associated with his patronage; after his deposition, work was continued by his pupil Paul, abbot of the monastery.
The chronology is not entirely closed. Dendrochronological data have placed the monument in or just after 1329, and current research suggests that the building may have been left unfinished when Niphon was removed from office in 1314 and completed later. The mosaics are generally associated with Niphon's patronage and so with the years 1310–1314, but the evidence for a later completion of the building should be kept in mind when the decoration is dated more narrowly.
Constantinople or Thessaloniki: The Question of the Workshop
The head of Elijah bears directly on a long-standing debate about who made the mosaics. Maria Iakovleva summarises the issue in a paper delivered at St Petersburg University: stylistic similarities with the Kariye Camii mosaics of 1316–1321 led some scholars to propose that the metropolitan workshop later active at the Chora, or Constantinopolitan masters, executed the Holy Apostles mosaics, and certain iconographic details, such as the form of the Pantokrator's left hand in the dome and the Holy Mandylion, reveal close links with Constantinople.
Iakovleva also stresses what sets the Thessaloniki mosaics apart, namely a freer drawing and a more painterly rendering of forms than in Constantinopolitan monuments of the first quarter of the fourteenth century, giving them a pronounced Hellenistic character. Along with a different approach to ornament, these features led her to suggest that the mosaics could have been executed by local Thessalonian masters. The question remains open.
For the side of the argument that emphasises painterly freedom, the Elijah head provides a useful example. The swinging bands of the hair, the vivid blue accents and the abrupt changes of direction in the rows of tesserae across the cheek show a mosaicist attentive to movement and variation across the surface. Whether that freedom points to a Thessalonian hand or to a Constantinopolitan one working in a looser mode cannot be decided from a single head.
Loss, Plaster and Survival
Around the head the field is no longer gold. A warm brown setting bed shows through on all sides, and patches of it appear between the locks of hair where tesserae have fallen. The condition matches what is documented of the church's history: when the church was converted into a mosque, the gold tesserae were removed and the mosaics covered with plaster. The date of the conversion is variously given. Iakovleva places it between 1520 and 1530, while Toumpouri gives perhaps around 1455 or 1520.
The coloured tesserae of the head survived the loss of the gold ground and the subsequent covering with plaster. The church returned to Christian use in 1912, restoration campaigns in 1926–1928 and 1940–1942 removed the Ottoman plaster from the interior, consolidation followed the earthquake of 1978, and the mosaics were cleaned in 2002. The brown ground that now frames the prophet is, in effect, a record of that history, and it makes the coloured figure stand out more sharply than it would have done against the original gold.
