Byzantine Art

The Incredulity of Thomas Mosaic at Hosios Loukas

Incredulity of Thomas mosaic at Hosios Loukas: Christ before a closed door raising his right arm, Thomas bending towards his side, apostles on a gold ground
The Incredulity of Thomas, mosaic lunette above the south door of the narthex, katholikon of Hosios Loukas, eleventh century; the lower centre was cut by a later window.

Eleven apostles, a closed door and an unbroken field of gold fill the lunette above the south entrance of the narthex in the katholikon of Hosios Loukas. In the middle, Christ raises his right arm and draws back his mantle to uncover the wound in his side, while Thomas bends towards it with one finger extended. The Incredulity of Thomas at Hosios Loukas is one of the four narrative mosaics of the narthex (John 20:24–29), and the only one set above a door that leads out of the church. Its condition is uneven. Thomas has lost his head, and a window opened at a later date has cut away the lower centre of the composition. Enough survives, however, to follow both the arrangement of the scene and the reasoning that placed it here.

The monastery stands in central Greece, near Delphi, in the historical region of Phocis; responsibility for the monument now lies with the Ephorate of Antiquities of Boeotia. Its katholikon was probably built in the first quarter of the eleventh century. Most scholars accept 1011 as its date, although other chronologies have been put forward. With Daphni and Nea Moni on Chios, Hosios Loukas is inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List as one of three monastic churches whose gold-ground mosaics define the art of the period.

A Lunette above the Way Out

The narthex is a long rectangular hall with short curved ends, covered by three groin-vaulted bays and attached to the western side of the church. Marble revetment lines the lower walls. Mosaic covers the upper zone and the vaults. Doors open to the outside on the west and south. On the east wall are three more: the central Royal Door into the naos, and two smaller doors into the chapels on either side. An arcosolium is set into the north end.

The decoration of this space is compact and closely reasoned. Above the Royal Door a bust of Christ Pantokrator holds a Gospel book open at John 8:12, and with the Virgin and John the Baptist in the middle vault he completes a Deesis. On the east wall the Crucifixion (John 19:16–30) and the Anastasis flank him, each placed over the door to one of the chapels. Five saints in medallions occupy the west wall above the exit to the courtyard. Only two further narrative scenes appear, facing one another across the length of the hall: the Washing of the Feet (John 13:1–17) above the arcosolium on the north wall and, at the opposite end, the Incredulity.

Opinions on the date of the narthex mosaics differ slightly. Photographic archives generally assign them to the first half of the eleventh century. Ljubomir Milanović, whose 2013 study is the most thorough treatment of the scene, considers that they were probably executed around the middle of the century. Whether they belong to the same campaign as the naos mosaics, where the Virgin Hodegetria occupies the eastern tympanum of the north arm and John Chrysostom fills a conch above the marble revetment, is a separate question that the present scene cannot answer.

A broad soffit band frames the lunette. Gold strips cross diagonally to form a lattice of lozenges, with a small knot at each crossing. Most of the lozenges have a white ground filled with dark blue-green scrollwork, and at intervals a lozenge in blue carries a gold motif instead. Thin red lines edge the band on both sides. At the upper corners, outside the arch, the curved rims of two medallion busts belong to the decoration of the neighbouring surfaces.

Christ Before the Closed Doors

The composition is built around a doorway. A tall rectangular frame of pale, streaked tesserae, imitating veined marble, runs across almost the full height of the field, with its inner reveal set at an angle so that the opening seems to recede. The doors themselves are closed and rendered in warm golden-brown. Christ stands in front of them, larger than any of the apostles. Milanović suggests that he was raised on a step or low platform, as in the scene of the same subject in the crypt of the katholikon, but that part of the mosaic is gone.

The cross-nimbus, drawn in red lines on gold, surrounds a long, bearded face with brown hair falling to the left shoulder. The chiton is worked in gold and brown, with a dark clavus, and over it a deep blue himation descends from the left shoulder in heavy folds. Christ lifts his right arm high, palm turned outward, and a dark spot at the centre of the palm marks the nail wound. His left hand grasps the edge of the himation at the waist and pulls it aside, opening the garment along the right flank beneath the raised arm. Red bands appear at both wrists. The gesture serves two purposes at once: the raised hand displays one wound, and the movement of the arm exposes the other.

On each side of the doorway stand five apostles, and Thomas is a sixth figure on Christ’s right. The group therefore numbers eleven, as the Gospel narrative requires. According to Polyvios Konis, cited by Milanović, monumental art first showed all eleven at Sant’Apollinare Nuovo in Ravenna. Byzantine versions of the scene vary in several respects: the number of apostles, the symmetry of the groups, the side on which the wound is shown, and whether the door is included at all. At Hosios Loukas the apostles are all present, the groups are almost symmetrical, and the door occupies the centre of the field.

Below Christ, the semicircular window cuts into the field. Its plaster panel, pierced with lobed and circular openings and lightly incised with ornament, has replaced the lower part of Christ’s figure and the step on which he stood.

“The Doors Being Shut”: The Inscription

Above the lintel, in dark majuscules on the gold ground, runs the inscription ΤΩΝ ΘΥΡΩΝ ΚΕΚΛΕΙΣ|ΜΕΝΩΝ. The words break after the seventh letter of the participle, and the second line is placed directly beneath the start of the first. The omega takes the rounded, minuscule-like shape found in many mosaic inscriptions. The phrase is the genitive absolute of John 20:26, “the doors being shut”, and it describes how Christ entered the room.

This choice of title is significant. Early images of the subject used other wording. An ampulla from Monza of about 600 carries Thomas’s confession, “My Lord and my God” (John 20:28), and an eighth-century painting at Santa Maria Antiqua in Rome simply reads APOSTOLI. The formula used at Hosios Loukas seems to have entered art around the tenth century, probably on a Constantinopolitan ivory now at Dumbarton Oaks. Konis connected it with the liturgy: the Jerusalem lectionary began the Gospel reading for Thomas Sunday at verse 26, whereas the typikon of Hagia Sophia began at verse 24. The inscription thus directs attention to the doorway beneath it, and therefore to a body that passes through closed doors. In Milanović’s reading, the closed door and the wound together establish both natures of Christ: the door his divinity, the wound his humanity.

Thomas and the Withheld Touch

Thomas stands at Christ’s right, immediately left of the doorframe as the viewer sees it. He bends forward from the hips in a pale himation whose folds are drawn in dark, angular lines. The hand he stretches out stops just short of Christ’s side, its forefinger aimed at the wound, and a second, lower hand opens near his waist. Where his head should be, the mosaic has been lost, and the gap has been filled with a flat surface toned to approximate the gold. The loss obscures much of the figure’s expression, yet the posture conveys the moment clearly.

Middle Byzantine art had two main ways of showing this encounter. In one, Thomas reaches towards the wound without touching it. In the other, Christ takes Thomas by the hand and guides it to his side. The katholikon itself contains an example of the second type: the crypt fresco shows Christ guiding the apostle’s hand. Carolyn Connor, cited by Milanović, considered that the crypt image was probably altered from an earlier version that resembled the narthex scene. The narthex mosaic follows the first type and leaves the question unresolved, which is also how the Gospel text leaves it. John 20:27–29 records the invitation and the confession without saying whether Thomas actually touched the wound. Christ offers his body for inspection, and the image leaves the outcome undetermined.

Other eleventh- and twelfth-century churches carried the same subject on a monumental scale, among them Daphni, the Church of the Nativity at Bethlehem (1169) and the cathedral of Monreale. The large number of examples after Iconoclasm reflects the debates of that period: a Christ who could be touched could also be depicted, and the resurrection of the body had to be visible.

The Apostles at Christ’s Right, Seen Closely

Heads of five bearded apostles in white garments with red and brown stripes, mosaic detail with small tesserae on gold
Detail of the apostles standing at Christ’s right, their faces modelled in curved rows of small tesserae against the gold ground.

The detail of the left-hand group shows the technique of the mosaic most clearly. Five closely grouped heads overlap, and only the last, bald and grey-bearded, is cut off by the edge of the crop. The first apostle has short, dark, curling hair receding from the forehead and a dense black beard, and he looks sideways towards the centre of the scene. Beside him, slightly higher, is a head in three-quarter view with straight hair parted in the middle and a full brown beard. The third has wavy hair and a long pointed beard. The fourth, with curly hair and a shorter reddish-brown beard, turns his gaze towards Christ. The physiognomies differ in deliberate ways, and no name inscriptions survive to identify the men.

Each face is laid in small tesserae arranged in curved rows that follow the forms beneath: arcs across the forehead, short runs down the bridge of the nose, and concentric lines around the cheeks. Dark tesserae draw the contours of brows, eyelids and nostrils. Pink and salmon tones carry the flesh, with white set along the cheekbones and below the eyes, and red picks out the lips and the edges of the cheeks. The bald apostle’s beard is built from grey, white and blue-green tesserae rather than brown. In the gold ground, the cubes are larger and less regular, and around each head its rows bend to follow the outline of the hair. The halo-like ring of setting lines is a result of how the mosaicists worked, as they placed the figure first and then filled the background around it.

Compared with the faces, the garments are coarser in execution. White and pale grey tesserae make up the tunics, with grey-green and soft violet in the folds, and broad clavi in red, brown and black run from the shoulders. One apostle holds his open hand flat against his chest. Lower down, another grips a closed scroll, shown as a pale cylinder with dark ends, and a further hand, half closed, rests at the level of the waist. The fingers are separated by single lines of dark tesserae. Seen from the floor of the narthex, these heavy outlines would remain legible at a distance.

The Incredulity of Thomas at Hosios Loukas and the Narthex Programme

Milanović interprets the scene through the movement of people across the narthex in both directions. Entering, a visitor passes the Anastasis and the Crucifixion on the way to the Pantokrator above the Royal Door. Leaving by the south, the same visitor sees the Incredulity above the doorway. He reads the two Resurrection images together. The Anastasis, in his view, asserts Christ’s victory over death and his divine nature. The Incredulity, through Thomas’s need for physical proof, confirms a resurrection of the body. Across the hall, the Washing of the Feet repeats the theme of physical contact with Christ and recalls the preparation for the Last Supper (Matthew 26:26–28).

The Eucharistic dimension of this argument depends partly on evidence from outside Hosios Loukas. The katholikon’s own typikon has not survived. Rules of other eleventh- and twelfth-century monasteries mention the diaklysmos, a modest distribution of bread and wine after the liturgy, held in the narthex while the monks waited to be called to the refectory. At Hosios Loukas the refectory lay on the south side of the church. Monks leaving for their meal would therefore have walked out beneath Christ and his wound. Milanović presents this as a likely scenario, without documentary confirmation. The funerary uses of the narthex are similarly reconstructed: the arcosolium and the commemorative themes of the adjacent north-west chapel suggest that services for the dead were held there, although no burial in the narthex itself is recorded.

The placement over the doorway is the most direct evidence. A mosaic doorway appears immediately above a real one. Milanović notes that, if the south entrance belongs to the original fabric, the scene was positioned to echo the opening beneath it. On this reading the closed doors behind Christ stand for the entrance to eternal life, and his exposed wound shows the way through them. A later example shows that this pairing of scene and doorway was repeated elsewhere: at the church of the Ascension at Mileševa, painted around 1228–1234, the Incredulity occupies the west wall of the narthex directly above the door to the exonarthex.