Carl Frederik Aagaard: Deer beside a Lake (1888)
![]() |
| Carl Frederik Aagaard, Deer beside a Lake, 1888. Oil on canvas, 53 × 82 cm. Private collection. |
In Deer beside a Lake, an oil on canvas painted in 1888 by the Danish landscape painter Carl Frederik Aagaard (1833–1895), the animals named in the title occupy only a small strip of sunlit grass near the water, while the trees around them fill almost the entire canvas. Massive trunks rise from a shadowed forest floor, their limbs meeting overhead, and through the opening between them a lake extends into a pale, misty distance. The picture measures 53 by 82 centimetres and is in a private collection.
Aagaard was born in Odense and worked for most of his life in Copenhagen, where he died. By 1888 he was an established figure: elected a member of the Danish Academy in 1874, he would receive the title of professor four years after this canvas was painted. Deer beside a Lake belongs to the mature years of a career built largely on the close observation of Danish woodland and water. Its ambition lies less in its subject, which is modest, than in the handling of a single problem, sunlight entering a dense wood.
Composition of Deer beside a Lake
The design rests on two great trunks. At the left edge one leans towards the frame, its upper part cut off, and from the upper part of the canvas a long limb curves across towards the centre. A little to the right of the middle stands the larger tree, branching above the clearing, its roots spreading over the bank, its limbs bending back towards the left, so that the branches of the two trees form an irregular arch. Beneath this arch the view opens. It is the only real opening in the picture.
On the right the wood thickens. Slender trunks recede in a loose row, one of them catching full light on its pale bark, and at the extreme right a heavier, darker trunk closes the composition, partly outside the frame. The trees appear to be beeches, to judge from the smooth grey and ochre bark and the flat sprays of broad oval leaves, although the painting itself carries no botanical precision beyond what the eye accepts at once.
Across the whole lower edge runs a band of reddish-brown earth in deep shade, crossed here and there by small patches of sun. Young growth spreads over the ground at the right. From this darkened foreground the viewer looks up and into the clearing, so that the picture is read in stages: shadow first, then the bright grass with the deer, then the water, and finally the hazy far shore beneath a sky that is almost white.
Light, Mist and the Handling of Foliage
The sun stands behind the trees, or high above them, and the painting is constructed against the light. Where the light passes through it, the canopy is translucent, a vivid yellow-green near the opening that darkens towards the right side of the picture and towards the top corners. Aagaard builds the foliage from a great number of small touches, leaf clusters laid one beside another, and the density of these touches varies with the light. In the brightest passages they almost dissolve.
The far side of the lake is treated quite differently. Tall trees on the opposite bank are reduced to blue-grey verticals softened by mist, their reflections drawn down into silvery water in long, faint strokes. Atmospheric perspective of this kind is conventional enough, but here it serves a definite pictorial purpose: the cool, vaporous distance sets off the warm ochres of the near trunks and the red-brown ground, and the contrast gives the shallow clearing a sense of depth it would not otherwise have.
Careful modelling defines the trunks. The central tree is lit along one flank, its bark mottled with greys, greens and pale ochres, while its far side sinks into shadow; at its base the roots are picked out with small highlights where they break the surface of the bank. Sunlight falling on the forest floor is rendered as scattered flecks of orange and gold, a device that ties the foreground to the bright zone beyond and keeps the shaded band from becoming a dead area.
The Deer in the Sunlit Clearing
The deer gather in the grass between the two principal trunks, close to the edge of the water. One stands upright with its head raised. Beside it, a smaller animal lowers its head to graze, and to the right, towards the foot of the central tree, two or three more lie resting in the grass, at least one of them with its head lifted. No antlers can be made out on any of them, and the painted forms are too small to allow the species to be determined with confidence.
Their placement is precise. They lie exactly where shade gives way to light and where the forest meets the lake, on the one strip of open ground in the composition, and their small scale makes the trees seem larger still. The title gives them first place; the picture gives them a role closer to that of animal staffage, enlivening and measuring the landscape. The stillness of the group, with two animals standing, one of them grazing, and the others at rest, suits the quiet of the whole scene.
The title names no place. Nothing in the painting allows the lake or the wood to be identified with certainty, and it may combine observed motifs with studio arrangement.
Carl Frederik Aagaard and the School of P. C. Skovgaard
Aagaard came to Copenhagen at nineteen and first trained in printmaking under his older brother Johan, a specialist in woodcut, learning wood engraving and etching while attending the Academy and studying decorative painting with G. C. Hilker. He then left the Academy to become a pupil of the landscape painter P. C. Skovgaard, one of the principal figures of the Danish Golden Age. Skovgaard's national-romantic conception of nature, his detailed rendering and his attention to changing conditions of light left a clear mark on the younger painter, whose favourite motifs came from the Mølleå river valley, Rådvad and the area around his home in Østerbro.
The detailed foliage and the carefully staged fall of light in Deer beside a Lake stand firmly within that inheritance. In the 1870s Aagaard twice travelled to Italy, and the sketches he made there served as the basis for later studio paintings, a working method described in the Fondation Custodia entry on an early oil sketch of clouds by him. The painting of 1888 shows that, after those journeys, the Northern woodland remained central to his work.
He was also active throughout his career as a decorative painter, first under Hilker and Heinrich Hansen and later more independently, directing decorative schemes at Aarhus Cathedral, the Royal Danish Theatre and the Dagmar Theatre. In such collaborative projects Aagaard often painted the landscapes while other artists supplied the figures. The habit of treating landscape as the main business of a picture, with figures in a supporting role, is visible in the easel paintings too, and the deer of 1888 are a small instance of it.
A comparable concern with a single, demanding light effect appears in a smaller canvas of 1880 now at Vassar College, showing visitors on the north shore of the Kullen peninsula in Sweden in the strong light of a long summer evening. There the light comes across open coast; in Deer beside a Lake it has to find its way through leaves, and most of the painting's work goes into following it there, from the bright gap in the canopy down to the flecks of sun on the reddish ground at the viewer's feet.
